Despite All the Misinformation, EVs Are Good for Michigan's Economy, Health, and Environment.

You've probably heard one or two myths about EVs. Here are some facts about EVs:

Investing in electric vehicle manufacturing will energize Michigan's economy.

Michigan’s growing EV manufacturing industry is boosting economic growth in communities and local economies throughout the state, while strengthening the state’s automotive workforce. Michigan was named the national leader in the EV battery and clean energy race, fostering $21.3 billion in new projects with 16,600+ jobs created, and 167,000 jobs projected.

With federal tax rebates, EVs are becoming more affordable.

The expanded EV tax credit in the IRA allows car buyers at all income levels to claim up to $7,500 in tax credits for purchasing a new electric vehicle. There are new EVs on the market starting at $28,000, and as EV manufacturing and battery production increases in the United States, EVs will become even more affordable. 

EVs put Michigan in a prime position to continue to lead in global automotive manufacturing.

Michigan workers make great cars, electric and otherwise, and they know Michigan needs to stay competitive in the global race for quality electric vehicles. While we already produce several industry-leading EVs in the auto state, much more is coming, thanks to recent announcements making Michigan the leading state for bringing home federal IRA investments for EV and battery manufacturing.

EVs are NOT mandated.

While there have been some misleading claims in the popular media on this point, the federal government does not mandate the use of EVs. EVs are one of the options that automakers have to help them meet vehicle fuel economy standards, and there are several incentives and other programs available that help make the technology more accessible to American drivers. Federal tax incentives also encourage the purchase of electric vehicles and batteries that are made in the United States. 

EVs are GOOD for the environment. 

EVs are a lower-emissions option than cars with internal combustion engines. A recent Bloomberg report confirms that EV lifecycle emissions can be over 70% lower than gasoline and diesel vehicles. EVs create 3,932 lbs. of CO2 equivalent per year, compared to 11,435 lbs. for gasoline vehicles. Said simply, EVs produce way less pollution. A safer, smoother ride with less maintenance and cleaner air!

EVs are GOOD for consumers, too. 

EVs are significantly cheaper to fuel and maintain than their gasoline counterparts.  The cost of electricity, for example, is much less volatile and at least half the price of gas. With fewer moving parts, they are also cheaper to maintain.  With federal incentives and rebates backed by the Biden-Harris administration, EVs are becoming increasingly more affordable. 

The bottom line: 

There's a lot of damaging misinformation about EVs being spread by the naysayers right now. We hope you consider the source of that information and know that EVs are critical to ending our dependence on fossil fuels, reducing pollution, and improving our health. Investing in a cleaner, more sustainable auto industry now ensures that Michigan is prepared to lead the auto industry in the future. 

EV Benefits

In Vitro Endocrine and Cardiometabolic Toxicity Associated with Artificial Turf Materials

For multiple years, Ecology Center has been testing the impact of artificial turf plastics, revealing some significant findings. Collaborating with national artificial turf campaigners, Chris Kassotis at Wayne State University, and his students (notably Kyle Siegel and Brooklynn Murray), a new study was published providing initial evidence of endocrine disruption and cardiometabolic health impacts from artificial turf plastics. Cardiometabolic diseases include heart attacks, strokes, diabetes, insulin resistance, and non-alcoholic fatty liver disease.

Published in the journal "Science of the Total Environment," the study has broader implications for understanding how plastics behave when exposed to environmental conditions. This extensive research, which spanned several years, underscores the need for further investigation into turf-associated chemical exposures and their potential impacts on human health. Meanwhile, Chris Kassotis's team and other researchers are actively engaged in two additional artificial turf studies, striving to deepen our understanding of these critical issues.

Link to the Artificial Turf Paper

Citation: Kyle R. Siegel, Brooklynn R. Murray, Jeff Gearhart, Christopher D. Kassotis. (2024). "In vitro endocrine and cardiometabolic toxicity associated with artificial turf materials." Environmental Toxicology and Pharmacology, 111https://doi.org/10.1016/j.etap.2024.104562 

How Our Stuff Can Be Reused to Welcome & Build Community

By Crystal Zanders

Our More Life, Less Stuff campaign, a partnership of the City of Ann Arbor and the Ecology Center, is sharing stories about building community, strengthening our connections, and celebrating life, all while using less stuff.   

The More Life, Less Stuff campaign is about rethinking our relationship with stuff and reimagining ways that our stuff, once no longer needed, can serve our community. As our lives and needs change, we don't have to add items in good condition to landfills. We can share those items with our neighbors and use them to serve and support our community members, especially our newest members. We spoke with volunteers from two community organizations, the Washtenaw Refugee Welcome (WRW) and the House By the Side of the Road, to learn about the folks who need help, how to access help, and what we can do to support these organizations that perform the vital services of welcoming our neighbors and ensuring folks have what they need. 

The Washtenaw Refugee Welcome is Empowering Neighbors to Help Neighbors.

Emmeline Weinert
We talked to WRW founding board member Emmeline Weinert to learn more about their program. 

Washtenaw Refugee Welcome works exclusively with refugees and their families.  In Washtenaw County, refugees work with Jewish Family Services, a resettlement agency licensed by the government to help refugees find a place to live and get established.  After three months, much of that government financial support goes away, but refugees often still need help. That is where Washtenaw Refugee Welcome (WRW) comes in.  

Since 2016, WRW, an all-volunteer non-profit, has supported refugees in our community. According to Emmeline, WRW volunteers "create social opportunities, facilitate getting household items and donations to refugees, act as a familiar face and a helping hand in the community." They do everything from hosting events for pumpkin painting and a Thanksgiving potluck to answering questions about mysterious mail and parental concerns about a child's school.  

Pumpkin Painting Washtenaw Refugee Welcome Event

One of the main things they do is connect refugees with other community organizations that provide support, like Food Gatherers, House By the Side of the Road, and the Hope Clinic food pantry.  

When asked what she is most proud of, Emmeline Weinert responded, "I'm proud of the families who continue to come to our events. Some families resettled years ago and are still at our Thanksgiving Potluck because we were their initial family and support system when they came to the area. And so often, those are our best advocates out in the community. They meet a neighbor who's a refugee or something like that, and then they bring them in." Washtenaw Refugee Welcome makes a difference in the lives of neighbors who, as refugees, by definition, have struggled to get to a place where they and their families can be safe. 

Thanksgiving Event for Washtenaw Refugee Welcome

What can I do to help?

There are many ways that we, as a community, can support the Washtenaw Refugee Welcome. The first is to donate money. Over 60 % of their budget last year came from individual donations. 86% of that budget went directly to supporting refugee families through programming, financial, and other support. 

We can also volunteer. Washtenaw Refugee Welcome is always looking for folks to help. When asked about volunteers, Emmeline encouraged folks to "Sign up to do the craft. Sign up to do the snack at a monthly meetup. Sign up to come to one of our picnics and maybe offer to drive a refugee family." If you are interested in volunteer opportunities, you can find more information here: https://www.washtenawrefugeewelcome.org/volunteer 

In the spirit of More Life, Less Stuff, we can donate goods in good condition. 

I think that's the beauty of when something isn't serving you, we don't hold onto it… we can give it to someone who can use it. Let's let our stuff serve the people we care about and want to care for. – Emmeline Weinert

Washtenaw Refugee Welcome always looks for small appliances such as countertop microwaves, kettles, pressure cookers, and vacuum cleaners. They also frequently need good-quality dishes, pots, pans, and household items. However, some items, such as diapers, soap, feminine pads, and laundry detergent, are not appropriate to reuse. For more information on those items, check out their Amazon wishlist

Emmeline also explained that they are looking for old-fashioned, reel-to-reel push lawnmowers (not electric, not gas) for larger families renting houses requiring lawn care. When they receive these donations, they immediately take them to the families that need them. 

Washtenaw Refugee Welcome Kids Story time and pumpkin painting

As previously stated, one of the main goals of Washtenaw Refugee Welcome is to connect refugees with trusted community organizations and services where they can get help. One such organization is House by the Side of the Road. 

The House By the Side of the Road Has Been Giving Back to the Community Since 1970. 

House By the Side of the Road is another all-volunteer organization that takes gently used goods and distributes them to the community free of charge. Essentially, they operate a thrift shop where folks in the community who need help can "shop" for free. They have a variety of goods, including bedding, clothing (especially winter gear), and shoes for kids and adults. If you need help and live in Washtenaw County, House By the Side of the Road only requires that you bring an ID or other proof or Washtenaw County residency.  Clients do not need to make an appointment or have a referral to stop by and get needed items. They are open for clients Monday through Friday from 10 am to 2 pm. Come by and get stuff. 

They also accept donations of goods they stock for folks who come in and cash, which is used to support the organization's operations. 

We visited House By the Side of the Road to learn more about their program and talk with their volunteers and manager – watch their story here: 

 

Washtenaw Refugee Welcome and House By the Side of the Road help us show that we care by sharing resources like household goods and clothing and giving money and time when we can. Amazing people throughout our community are working together to ensure our neighbors know they are valued and important and that we, as a community, care about each other. We can come together as a community to welcome our newest members and help provide access to the resources they need to build a life here and thrive.  

 

How do refugees get from their home countries to Washtenaw County?
Refugees are folks who have been displaced from their homes and cannot return because it is not safe, often due to violence, persecution, or human rights concerns. This applies to millions of people across the globe. Currently, 117.3 million people throughout the world are forcibly displaced.

To become refugees, they must first flee their homes and cross an international border. Then, they apply to the United Nations High Commissioner for Refugees (UNHCR) for refugee status. UNHCR evaluates whether each person qualifies as a refugee. However, qualifying for refugee status doesn't automatically mean they get to move to another country. Each country only allows so many refugees to resettle. The UNHCR prioritizes the folks who are most at risk in their home country and the country they fled to. When selected, the UN refers people to a host country that does its own, often intensive, screening to decide whether or not to accept them. It is a long and arduous process that can take years.

If accepted in the US, they get three months of support through a resettlement agency that works with the State Department. The resettlement agency in Washtenaw County is the Jewish Family Services. This agency is licensed and partially funded by the government to help refugees find a place to live and get established. After three months, much of the government's financial support for refugees has disappeared, but refugees often still need help. That is where Washtenaw Refugee Welcome (WRW) comes in.

“I know that I’m doing my part to bring about change and justice”: An Interview with Salam Beydoun, Environmental Justice Organizer

Salam Beydoun, Environmental Justice Organizer at the Ecology Center, brings a unique perspective to environmental justice and equity, shaped by her heritage and experiences growing up in Dearborn, MI. With roots in Southern Lebanon, Salam’s journey portrays an unwavering commitment to justice, community, and environmental advocacy. Her path, which includes an educational background in Philosophy, Sociology, and Social Work from Wayne State University, led her to focus on environmental justice, particularly in the Detroit and Dearborn areas.

Drawing from personal experiences and daily challenges faced by her community, Salam is passionate about addressing the intersections of injustice. Her work emphasizes air quality advocacy within Southeast Michigan, aiming to connect the dots between air pollution and other critical issues affecting our cities, like affordable housing, food insecurity, and poverty. In her role at Ecology Center, Salam is dedicated to empowering residents and community members to speak out about injustice, ensuring their voices are heard and their needs addressed.

Since joining the Ecology Center in 2023, Salam has been instrumental in coordinating community education initiatives, such as DIY Box Fan Air Filter workshops, to combat poor air quality exacerbated by factors such as industrial pollution and wildfire smoke. She also played a key role in the newly launched Clear the Air coalition, organizing events for Air Quality Awareness Week 2024 and pushing for legislative policies to protect vulnerable and unproportionally-impacted communities.

We had the opportunity to speak with Salam about her journey, her work at the Ecology Center, and her vision for a just and equitable future for all communities.

(This interview has been edited for clarity and length.)


 

Tell us a little bit about yourself – where are you from? What did you do for fun as a kid? What did you study in school? What specific life experiences, interests, or ambitions led you on that path?

I grew up in Dearborn, MI, both of my grandfathers were immigrants from Southern Lebanon who came in the late 60s/early 70s and worked for Ford. As a kid I loved playing outside, doing somersaults in the front yard of my parents’ home. I grew up playing football with my dad and brother, joined a basketball league when I was eight and a volleyball team when I was ten and continued playing those sports up until high school. Moving my body has always been an essential part of my life and continues even now as I practice and teach yoga.

I went to Wayne State for both my undergraduate and graduate degrees. I studied Philosophy and Sociology in undergrad, with the initial goal of becoming a lawyer. I have always been drawn to helping people, and the profession fits my parents’ approval of acceptable careers. After graduating with my Bachelor of Arts in 2019, I realized that it wasn’t the right avenue for me. This led me down a path of trying to decide what to do with a degree that didn’t mean much to most employers, while still trying to feel that I was doing my part in advocating for justice and vulnerable people. During the George Floyd and BLM protests in combination with the #SaveSheikhJarrah in Palestine campaign during the summer of 2020, I felt drawn to the organizing that went behind these powerful movements. I eventually found myself applying to Wayne State’s School of Social Work after learning that there was a tract designed to train social workers, like myself, to become community leaders and organizers. During the program, my personal focus became environmental justice, especially in Detroit and Dearborn, knowing that it’s a crucial point where almost all injustices meet.

I don’t think any one specific instance led me to this point – rather, a conglomeration of all my experiences and the identities I hold. Being a second-generation Lebanese Muslim woman growing up in Dearborn, I was surrounded by others with a similar background as myself. The majority of my friends and I are from families displaced by war and occupational forces causing instability in our Southern villages, so I grew up hearing stories about discrimination for our religious background and race from those around me. This strengthened my internal pull towards wanting to know more about the systems that perpetuate it. Even in religion, our duties as Muslims are to be advocates for justice when we witness oppression or injustice, as we are meant to be protectors of the environment and one another. “In Islam, love is not just a feeling, but a responsibility; to care for, support, and uplift one another in goodness and righteousness,” @Soul.Guider on Instagram. All of this and more brought me to this point, and while I can’t do it all, I know that I’m doing my part to bring about change and justice, acting in alignment with my value system.

You joined the Ecology Center in 2023 as an ​​Environmental Justice Organizer, a new position at our organization. Can you tell us your hopes for this position and the work you’ll do in this position?

I’m excited to be doing work with the Ecology Center! I feel fortunate to be part of this organization and to do Air Quality advocacy and organizing within Dearborn and Detroit. Through my position, I hope to be able to draw connections to the intersections of injustice many people within Southeast Michigan face. Through air quality, we can see the negative effects on communities also facing a lack of affordable housing, food insecurity, poverty, unreliable public transportation, and so much more. Ultimately, I’d like to have a network of organizers and organizations who are willing to connect our issues and empower residents and community members to be advocates for their own change. Using my social work background, it’s necessary to emphasize the needs of the community first, and I hope we can work together to identify those issues and work towards a more just and equitable future.

In the meantime, much of my work involves community education around air quality issues, especially with regard to the wildfire smoke that impacted us last summer. We only anticipate this to continue and find it necessary to provide affordable and accessible ways to mitigate it. There are plans to host DIY Box Fan Filter workshops throughout the summer to supplement the education and resources. These workshops will be co-hosted with partner organizations throughout Detroit with the intent of showing residents and community members how simple it is to assemble their own indoor air purifier with materials found at any supply store. It’s important and necessary to make this type of health impact easily accessible.

As a native of Dearborn, which has historically experienced poor air quality due to the extensive industrial properties in Dearborn, Melvindale, and Detroit, what does EJ advocacy work mean to you?

Admittedly, I grew up in the better part of Dearborn, not so close to industry (like the Ford Rouge Plant or Cleveland Cliffs Steel Plant) affecting the air quality around me. I did have several family members work for these industries, however, and saw the negative health impact  for those who were exposed to it daily, causing cancers and respiratory issues. Environmental Justice advocacy means understanding my privilege of not having lived in areas that would have negatively impacted my own health AND knowing my responsibility to be an advocate for those who are impacted. The communities living in the shadow of these polluting industries are majority Black, Latinx, and Arab, and so many within these communities are immigrants who may not have access to the language or resources to advocate on behalf of themselves. It’s our duty to tap into these communities and really understand the harms that are being done and ask them what they need in order to live with the right to breathe clean air.

The Clear the Air coalition launched in May during AQ awareness week. What did the week look like? 

Through the new Clear the Air coalition, I coordinated a week of events for Air Quality Awareness Week, which was May 6 –10 this year. The week was in coordination with other members of the coalition and partner organizations. We had film showings about air quality and pollution in Detroit and Dearborn, showing the industries contributing to the harm of residents who live around them. There was also a panel discussion on Tuesday, May 7th hosting coalition members, community leaders, and health researchers talking about the need for cumulative impact policy on a local and state level – the purpose of the coalition is to educate communities about it and push these policies forward. We had a DIY Box Fan Filter workshop with parents in Southwest Detroit, educating them on how to use these in their homes to mitigate poor indoor air quality, especially as the summer and wildfire smoke season approached us. A press conference in Dearborn’s Southend was also held to emphasize the close proximity of the steel plant to the elementary and middle school, impacting the health of everyone who lives and goes to school nearby. The DIY Box Fan Filter workshop and press conference were among a full week of events through SE Michigan. 

Air Quality Awareness Week was educational, allowing residents and community members to learn more about what cumulative impact policies are and what it means for their health. We provided resources for folks to learn about how to mitigate poor air quality days and how poor air impacts our lungs, and who is most susceptible to its impacts. Air Quality Awareness week provided folks with an opportunity to learn about who is in their community and to build relationships in the fight for our right to clean air.

You also teach yoga. How does that teaching inform your work at the Ecology Center?

I have been practicing yoga sporadically over the last 10 years, and more seriously through the last 4 years. Yoga has been a grounding force as I pushed through grad school, helping me maintain a healthy balance between self care and community care. Feeling so grateful to have learned a way to recenter and ground myself, it was only natural that I pursued my yoga teaching certification so that I could share this knowledge with others who might also benefit from the healing nature of the practice. Teaching yoga is a selfless service, the focus always on the student and showing up for themselves. I’m a mere guide on their journey to self-discovery and self-determination.

So many of the tools I have learned through teaching transfers over into my work with the community, with an emphasis on meeting people where they are. Yoga is a practice meant to honor our bodies and to be patient as we learn to tap into the mind-body connection. When working with others and organizing, I have learned to reflect on this principle when considering the life experiences of those I have the privilege of working with by leading my work with openness and curiosity, while leaving assumptions at the door. I’ve learned to apply it to myself as I started this position a year ago. I have had to learn to be patient with myself, giving myself grace to take time to learn the skill sets I need and make the connections necessary to do the work. Above all, yoga encourages me to be intentional and present, encouraging balance on and off the mat. This work can require a lot out of us because there’s always something to do, it’s nice to have that gentle reminder to come back to myself and recenter. As Audre Lorde has said, “Caring for myself is not self-indulgence, it is self-preservation, and that is an act of political warfare.” We must fill our own cups before pouring into others to sustain ourselves in this very demanding work.

Diverse coalition says clean energy laws will help U.P. lower costs, reduce pollution

During MPSC hearing, groups renewed support for state’s clean energy standards

Marquette, Mich. — A diverse coalition of organizations is repeating its support for Michigan’s clean energy laws following a Michigan Public Service Commission (MPSC) hearing on the Upper Peninsula’s (U.P.) implementation of the clean energy standards on Tuesday, July 30.

Last year, Michigan lawmakers passed legislation to transition to 100% clean energy by 2040 from sources such as wind and solar power — giving Michigan the most robust energy efficiency standards in the country, while helping to address energy affordability, health and safety for many low-income households.     

“Michiganders pay the highest rates for electricity for the worst electric utility services in the Midwest,” said Ashley Rudzinski, climate and environment program director for Groundwork Center. “On top of that, many Yoopers pay the highest electric rates in Michigan. It’s time to hold utility companies accountable for rising costs, bad service and pollution in our air and water. The Upper Peninsula can transition to 100% renewable, clean energy by 2040 and help reduce carbon pollution that is disrupting our climate.”

The coalition has pledged to beat back any efforts to undermine the law while asking the MPSC to help move Michigan to cleaner, renewable energy.

“We must protect the Great Lakes we rely on for our economy, drinking water and way of life by implementing the 100% clean energy standard,” said Charles Griffith, Ecology Center climate & energy program director. “New technologies and renewable energy innovations are being developed every day and costs continue to come down, and it would be premature to say the U.P. will not be able to implement the clean energy standard by goals more than a decade away.”

Measuring the cost of different forms of energy, an analysis found that clean, renewable energy sources, like wind and solar, are cheaper than coal and natural gas, even without subsidies.

“Michigan lawmakers passed groundbreaking legislation that will help lower the cost of our utility bills and ensure we have cleaner air to breathe and water to drink by transitioning to clean, renewable energy,” said Carlee Knott, energy and climate policy coordinator for the Michigan Environmental Council. “Our fellow Michiganders in the Upper Peninsula deserve the same opportunities to create new good-paying jobs and reduce pollution by generating clean energy.”

“It’s time for the big utilities — everywhere in our great state — to move toward 100% clean energy by 2040,” said Derrell Slaughter, Michigan policy director, climate and energy, at NRDC. “We owe it to our kids and grandkids in the U.P. to protect them and their futures. Renewable energy will provide cleaner air to breathe and water to drink, improve public health, and save lives.”

“Reliable clean energy is essential to protecting human health”, said Elizabeth Del Buono, MD, president of Michigan Clinicians for Climate Action. “Michigan residents are experiencing the health impacts of fossil fuel pollution today, and it will only worsen as our climate changes. The good news is that transitioning to clean energy saves lives and health care dollars. People living in the Upper Peninsula deserve the opportunity to benefit from Michigan's 100% clean energy standard by 2040 without compromises.”

“U.P. residents have much to gain from the lower electric bills and enhanced reliability that more clean energy and energy efficiency can bring,” said Amy Bandyk, executive director of the Citizens Utility Board of Michigan. “We shouldn’t delay on rate relief for the U.P.”

“The Clean Energy Standard presents a transformative opportunity to secure a future where clean, reliable, and affordable energy is a reality for all U.P. residents,” said Tim Minotas, deputy legislative and political director at the Michigan Sierra Club. “Transitioning to a future powered by clean energy will enable the U.P. to capitalize on the financial support available through the Inflation Reduction Act, ultimately delivering the air and water and cost-saving benefits that clean energy provides.”

The following groups also expressed support for clean energy implementation in the U.P.:

  • Great Lakes Renewable Energy Association (GLREA)
  • Union of Concerned Scientists (UCS)

 

###

Sustainable Purchasing Guide for Candidates

Sustainable purchasing is fundamental to a healthy, prosperous, and resilient future. Sustainable purchasing can strengthen Michigan communities, support businesses, save money, and protect health and the environment.

The world is experiencing an unprecedented set of environmental and social challenges including a climate crisis, a pollution crisis, and a biodiversity crisis. Plastic pollution is now threatening ecosystems and human health. Residents of the State of Michigan confront these multiple environmental crises that threaten social stability, human and environmental health, and the economic fortunes of the State. All of these crises have roots in the materials we purchase and the energy we use.

procurement graphic -- 90% of impacts on air, soil, and water, and 80% of climate impacts are in the supply chain

Michigan’s climate plan lays out a pathway for Michigan to reach 100% carbon neutrality by 2050 to avert the worst impacts of the climate crisis, create good-paying jobs, and build a healthier and more prosperous, equitable, and sustainable Michigan for all Michiganders.

Michigan will not reach that climate goal without a focus on sustainable purchasing. On average, 70% of climate emissions are in the products governments purchase every day including making products and transporting, using, and disposing of them. Michigan also can’t reach climate goals without focusing on plastics reduction. Plastics are a large and growing use of fossil fuels, so the State can’t just focus on reducing fossil fuels used to make energy. The State also needs to focus on reducing fossil fuel use to make new plastics. Sustainable purchasing also offers one of the most powerful ways to address the plastics crisis.

By adopting policies to prioritize the purchase of products that protect health and the environment, we can help address some of the most difficult and intractable environmental and social problems. Buying products that reduce energy use, do not contain toxic chemicals, are made under safe, sustainable, and fair conditions, can be reused, and don’t deplete resources and ecosystems helps build a more resilient future for all. Buying local, sustainable, fairly produced goods and services also supports Michigan’s economy and prosperity.

The State has already recognized that the products and services it buys have inherent environmental and economic impacts and that it should make procurement decisions that embody, promote, and encourage the state’s commitment to being environmentally, socially, and fiscally responsible. For example, Michigan was one of the first states in the country to adopt a strong purchasing policy to eliminate PFAS, “Reducing State Purchases of Products Containing Intentionally Added PFAS.” For information on state PFAS policy, please see the SAFER PFAS Guide. The State should extend that commitment and adopt a strong policy to reduce other pollutants and greenhouse gas emissions through sustainable purchasing.

Voters want legislators to take action!

In a national poll taken by NRDC, voters clearly signaled their interest in action on plastics, one of the big product categories purchased by states. In order to address this concern, a strong statewide sustainable purchasing policy is necessary.

voters want less plastic

Cities, institutions, and states are taking action

Cities and states across the country and the world are implementing successful sustainable purchasing policies and commitments that accelerate the purchase of products that are less toxic and less fossil fuel intensive, while still performing equally well and often saving money, particularly when energy and waste disposal requirements are considered. Michigan should join them.

  • Cities like Lansing and Ann Arbor and institutions like the University of Michigan have passed comprehensive sustainable purchasing policies and applied them to major contracts that offer a good roadmap for the state. They demonstrate that sustainable purchasing is not only possible, but necessary to address critical environmental and social issues and save taxpayer dollars.
  • States like New York, Minnesota, Maryland, California, and many others have strong sustainable purchasing policies that have been demonstrated to save money, protect health, and preserve the environment.

Benefits of taking action

In addition to saving money, sustainable purchasing is a powerful tool for all kinds of benefits including:

  • Supporting healthy communities and workforces
  • Ensuring the safety of Michigan's land, air, and water
  • Spurring economic development and creating good-paying jobs
  • Protecting and improving the health of Michiganders
  • Positioning Michigan as a leader in climate action and sustainability
  • Protecting our natural resources and wildlife
  • Addressing environmental injustices
  • Reducing liability and risk
  • Supporting the mission and values of the state
  • Modeling best practices
  • Supporting local businesses
  • Demanding safer products to help drive the market toward more innovation and safer materials for the future

Solutions

Michigan should adopt proposed legislation to use the purchasing power of the State of Michigan to promote health, protect communities, advance equity, localize supply chains, support economic development, save money, address the climate, plastics, chemicals, and biodiversity crises, provide a model for local units of government, and preserve Michigan’s natural resources.

What should the legislation do?

The legislation should put existing Michigan executive actions related to sustainable procurement in statute, and strengthen others to mirror best practice. The legislation should support the State of Michigan’s goal to minimize negative impacts on human health and the environment while supporting a vibrant community and economy. In addition, it should set preferences for desirable sustainability attributes when procuring goods and services. It also should establish policies and procedures for acquiring, developing, maintaining, and using specifications for goods and services that align with the State’s goals. The legislation should provide incentives to communities with sustainable purchasing policies when competing for state grant funds.

The legislation should also:

  • Empower State staff to be innovative and demonstrate leadership by incorporating progressive and best-practice environmental specifications, strategies, and practices in procurement decisions;
  • Encourage vendors and contractors to promote products and services that are most suited to the State’s environmental, social, and fiscally responsible principles and encourage the development of environmentally preferable products and services;
  • Complement existing State ordinances and policies; and
  • Communicate the State’s commitment to sustainable procurement by modeling the best product and service choices to other local units of government, other states, and the private sector.

Anticipated outcomes of sustainable procurement legislation:

  • Reduced occupational health hazards for State staff
  • Reduced exposure of State residents and visitors to toxic chemicals
  • Protected and improved air and water quality for Michigan residents and visitors
  • Reduced greenhouse gas emissions, energy use, and resource consumption, and associated cost savings
  • Reduced landfill waste and associated costs and liabilities
  • Reduced use of toxic chemicals and associated costs and liabilities
  • Alignment of State purchasing and use of materials, products, and services with the State’s fiscal, equity, environmental, climate change, toxics reduction, community, and performance goals

The following directives would be codified:

The policy would also:

  • Create an Office of Sustainable Procurement jointly funded by EGLE, MEDC, and MDHSS; use third party certifications where applicable; and favor products manufactured by companies that take financial and/or physical responsibility for collecting, recycling, reusing, or otherwise safely disposing of their products and packaging at the end of their useful life.
  • Offer potential opportunities for sustainable municipal procurement contracts to be bundled with state contracts.

Environmental factors to be considered in product and service acquisitions include:

  • Pollutant releases and toxicants, especially Persistent Bioaccumulative Toxics (PBTs), other chemicals of concern, air emissions, and water pollution; Transparency and full disclosure of ingredients and product details; Waste generation and minimization; Greenhouse gas emissions; Recyclability and recycled content; Energy consumption, energy and fuel efficiency, and use of renewable energy; Depletion of natural resources; Potential impact on human health and the environment; Impacts on biodiversity; Manufactured locally and/or locally sourced; Life cycle impacts and costs considered, including impacts on worker health and and safety and community impacts; Total cost of ownership or ‘value for money procurement’ instituted; Product durability, reusability and long-term performance considered; environmental performance of vendors.

More Life, Less Plastics

By Crystal Zanders

This Plastic Free July, Ann Arbor’s More Life, Less Stuff campaign is raising awareness about how our clothing habits and consumption contribute to plastic pollution in our local waterways – a literal river of microplastics making its way into our wildlife and bodies. The More Life, Less Stuff campaign is a partnership of the City of Ann Arbor and the Ecology Center. Learn more at a2morelife.com.

A few summers ago, my friends and I went tubing in the Huron River. It was my first time tubing, and to say I was concerned would be an understatement. I was terrified. I worried that the current would take me away because I am not a strong swimmer. I imagined an elaborate helicopter rescue saving me from careening over a waterfall. I knew there were fish in the water, and I imagined accidentally ingesting some fish poop and being infected by a rare fish-poop virus. I was sure that my friends were leading me into near-certain death, but courageously, as I mentally planned my funeral, I put on my big-girl bathing suit and a life jacket and spent an idyllic afternoon floating down the river. Looking back, I thought I understood the dangers of the Huron River, when I never even saw the danger floating beside me.

Crystal Zanders by waterway
Crystal Zanders, she/hers Doctoral Candidate in English and Education at the University of Michigan and freelance writer for the More Life, Less Stuff campaign

The Huron River — and every other river — is filled with plastic. Most bacteria don't eat plastic the way they eat natural materials to break them down. So, plastic doesn't decompose the way other materials do.  It just breaks down into smaller and smaller pieces over time, the smallest of which are called microplastics and nanoplastics. Because so much of our world is composed of plastic, microplastics and nanoplastics are everywhere. They are in the water, the air, and our bodies.

To learn more, I sat down with Ecology Center Senior Scientist Gillian Miller, Ph.D and asked some questions about this invisible threat flowing freely through our waterways.

How do microplastics get in the water?

One of the most significant contributors of microplastics to waterways is laundry.  Remember the bathing suit from my tubing adventure? According to the tag, it is 82% nylon and 18% spandex. Both materials are different kinds of plastic. Many of our clothes are made of plastic.  Each time we wash clothes, they break down a little bit. Fibers from those clothes are washed into the water.  

Dr. Miller explained what happens next: "Everything that goes down the drain in our homes gets treated at the wastewater treatment plant, and the liquid portion is discharged to rivers and waterways. The treatment doesn't remove all microplastics, so some get discharged that way directly into our waterways." With each load, a small amount of plastic goes into the water system and makes its way into larger bodies of water, including the Huron River.  

Why are microplastics a problem for our health? 

Microplastics have been found in nearly every organ and part of the body and in bodily fluids like blood, urine, and breast milk. Although we are just beginning to understand their effects, evidence already suggests harm.

Patients who had micro or nanoplastics in the plaques in their arteries were more likely to have a heart attack or stroke or die from any cause over a three-year follow-up period. These tiny plastic particles can also carry other hazardous chemicals with them, exacerbating harmful effects. They can harm the brain because the smallest particles can pass the blood-brain barrier, possibly increasing the risk of developing Parkinsons or Alzheimer's. In the lungs and other parts of the body, they can also cause inflammation. 

Microplastics are also dangerous to animals. According to Dr. Miller, microplastics "look like food to a lot of wild animals, including birds, turtles, and all kinds of fish." If they eat enough plastic instead of food, they could die. 

How can we help keep microplastics out of our waterways?

As individuals, the first thing we could do is buy less clothing. The more plastic clothes we buy, the more plastic clothes are produced. The more plastic clothes are produced, the more they break down into our air and waterways and eventually end up in landfills. The longer you can wear the clothes you have, the better for the environment.

If you need some clothing you don't already have, consider buying from thrift stores or other secondhand retailers or joining your local Buy Nothing group*. However, if and when you do buy clothing, Dr. Miller suggests you try to buy high-quality clothing that lasts a long time. When asked about materials, she said, "Natural materials in general are going to be better: wool and hemp and cotton," encouraging us to buy organic if that is within our budget. The issues around pesticide use in non-organic cotton production could warrant its own dedicated story. 

Also, we can do less laundry. For example, I wash my bathing suit every time I wear it, but I don't have to wash my jeans with the same frequency. The less often we wash our clothes, the less plastic we put into the water system. Also, the longer the clothes last. It has the added benefit of saving time and money. Win-win.

The longer you wear your clothes, the more value you get from them. That bathing suit was about $25 in 2014. If I have used it once per year for the last ten years, then I have used it ten times, making my cost per use $2.50. If I can keep it for another five years, that would bring my cost per use down to $1.66. The longer we use items, the more bang we get for our bucks. Higher quality clothes tend to last longer, often making them cheaper per use than cheap clothes that you may only be able to wear a few times before they become damaged. 

When clothes wear out, we can repurpose them. Growing up, we dusted using single socks, saving money by using what we already had rather than buying expensive dusters. My brother used to clean his car with soft, old t-shirts to ensure he wouldn't scratch the paint. These creative uses for our old items helped save money while protecting the environment and keeping our old clothing out of landfills.

We're ready to take the No New Clothes challenge. Are you?

Video 3 (Micro Plastics & Clothes) from Marcus Thomas on Vimeo.

And Don’t Forget to Vote!

According to Dr. Miller, the most important thing we can do is vote. She said, "Individual people cannot shop their way out of the microplastics problem. There have to be political solutions at the government level to these pollution and environmental destruction issues." Dr. Miller encourages us to let our representatives know that we care about environmental policy and that protecting our families and our world from microplastics is essential to us. 

As I think back to that day tubing on the river, I remember being awed by how beautiful it was to watch the water sparkle in the sunshine and feel connected to the community and the wildlife it sustains. Water is life, and keeping our waterways healthy is our responsibility.

*Stay tuned for our next story for the More Life, Less Stuff campaign about our local Sharing Economy and Buy Nothing groups!

Groups urge lawmakers to prioritize more funding for clean energy investments

Non-partisan groups thank lawmakers for including clean energy law implementation, funding for clean transportation, energy efficiency in state budget

LANSING, Mich. – A coalition of nonpartisan Michigan groups is thanking the Michigan Legislature for making critical investments to protect our air, land and water for the future of our state by passing the 2025 state budget, while urging them to provide more funding in these areas.

The state budget includes funding for the implementation of the state’s historic 100% clean energy standard, affordable energy and energy efficiency projects, clean mobility and transportation — but those investments are still only a fraction of what’s needed to protect Michiganders from rising costs while reducing pollution.

“The funding allocated for pre-weatherization, housing stock and homeowner affordability will help us make improvements to the quality, safety and affordability of Michigan’s existing attainable and low-income housing,” said Carlee Knott, energy and climate policy coordinator for the Michigan Environmental Council. “Much more funding is needed through a comprehensive whole-home approach so we can help ensure that our homes are free of pollutants, residents are staying cool in the summer and warm through the winter and homes are resilient to the effects of climate change. Energy efficient homes help save people money on utility bills and protect our air, land and water for generations to come.”

“With the transportation sector now the leading source of climate-changing emissions, Michigan’s 2025 budget makes some critical commitments to cleaner transportation options that will help us meet our state’s climate and pollution reduction goals and increase access to clean mobility for all Michiganders,” said Charles Griffith, climate and energy program director at the Ecology Center. “We’ve still got work to do if we want to be leaders in clean mobility, however, which will require consideration of new policy initiatives that set targets for clean vehicles and transportation emission reductions, and that raise new revenues to help support this critical transition.”

“We applaud the Michigan Legislature for their transformative investments in clean mobility,” said Jane McCurry, executive director of Clean Fuels Michigan. “These investments will not only advance the state’s transportation goals but also bolster Michigan’s position as a national leader in the clean mobility transition by developing our infrastructure, encouraging the deployment of cleaner vehicles and creating jobs in a rapidly growing sector.”

“We’re thrilled that Michigan is getting a statewide e-bike incentive program and so grateful to all the people who helped make it happen. E-bikes are the future. They’re a transformative, extremely popular form of affordable transportation with benefits for public health, climate goals and cleaner air. With this program, Michigan will join 10 other states that recognize their potential to make our streets less crowded and our commutes more joyful," said Matt Penniman, communications and advocacy director for the League of Michigan Bicyclists.

“While we appreciate the Legislature’s increased attention to transit this year, this budget falls far short of the transit operating funds Michigan needs,” said Megan Owens, executive director of Transportation Riders United. “Even as the Governor’s MI Healthy Climate Plan and Growing Michigan Together Council have called for significant investments in transit, these budget levels may result in cuts in transit service, especially in fragile rural communities. Our state must do better.”

“We applaud the Michigan Legislature for taking critical steps to further the state’s development of a thriving clean energy economy,” said Courtney Bourgoin, senior Midwest policy and advocacy manager at Evergreen Action. “These investments not only support the implementation of the state’s clean energy and energy efficiency goals, but will also create good-paying jobs, enhance the workforce with essential trainings and attract significant additional investment to Michigan. We must continue building on this progress to ensure that everyone in Michigan benefits from clean air, clean water, and affordable energy."

The coalition highlights the following allocations in the state budget:

Michigan’s 100% clean energy standard

  • $156.2 million in federal Inflation Reduction Act funding for Solar for All, which supports solar programs for low-income households to increase residential solar installation, increase pollution abatement and improve grid reliability
  • $7 million for implementation of the 2023 Clean Energy Jobs Act at the Michigan Public Service Commission
  • $5 million for grants to businesses, nonprofit organizations and units of local and state government for planning, developing, designing, acquiring or constructing renewable energy and electrification infrastructure projects
  • $5 million for Michigan’s nonprofit green bank (Michigan Saves)

Clean Buildings

  • $33.4 million for housing stock and homeowner affordability, which can be used to build new construction, renovate current homes and complete energy efficiency improvements
  • About $22 million for weatherization assistance with an additional $40 million in funds through the federal Infrastructure Investment and Jobs Act
  • $5 million for pre-weatherization projects, which will help protect our homes against the effects of climate change

Clean mobility and transportation

  • $30 million to add EV charging stations and hydrogen fueling facilities around Michigan
  • $1m for state fleet electric vehicle transition
  • Increase of $30 million for local bus operating for a total of $247 million
  • Increase of $14.5 million for rail operations and oversight for a total of $152 million
  • $2.95 million for E-bike purchase incentives
  • $2.5 million for the Economic and Worker Transition Office to aid Michiganders with the transition to electric vehicles and clean energy

###

Diverse coalition encourages passage of bipartisan community solar legislation

Groups say legislation would help lower energy costs while helping state transition to clean energy 

LANSING, Mich. — A diverse coalition of organizations is encouraging lawmakers to pass bipartisan-sponsored legislation that will enable and scale community solar across Michigan.

The Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) recently awarded a $156 million federal grant to Michigan for programs aimed at expanding solar access in low-income and disadvantaged communities. Michigan’s Department of Environment, Great Lakes, and Energy (EGLE) is responsible for utilizing the funding to finalize and implement programs that maximize benefits for low-income households and communities.

“We have a tremendous opportunity for EGLE to help ensure residents in underserved areas gain access to the economic and environmental benefits of solar power,” said Sergio Cira-Reyes, Climate Justice Catalyst, at the Urban Core Collective. “To do that we need a state policy framework that encourages the creation of third-party community solar projects, which ultimately will help provide cleaner air to breathe and water to drink for all Michigan residents. This important legislation would help improve public health, save lives and create equitable access to clean energy.”

Currently, Michigan does not allow independently owned community solar programs that local residents can subscribe to. Community solar projects in Senate Bills 152 and 153 would expand solar energy access to individuals who are limited due to income, rent a home that does not permit rooftop installation or who face other obstacles, such as the placement of their home or trees shading their home. 

Community solar programs are currently not allowed in the state despite the work of community organizations preparing to lead community solar development for more than a decade. They need access to the utility billing system so community members can receive credits on their bills from their community solar subscriptions. Additionally, these solar energy projects need to be connected to a utility company’s grid. 

Studies of community solar development show that local ownership expands financial benefits to households and local economies while generating more jobs, more engagement and more stability for the solar industry. 
“It is time for the Michigan Legislature to move community solar legislation forward so that we can expand access to clean solar energy to more Michiganders,” said Carlo Cavallaro, Midwest regional director of the Coalition for Community Solar Access. “Without Senate Bills 152 and 153, Michigan will miss out on the ability to tap into the hundreds of millions of dollars from third-party community solar developers’ investments into Michigan’s utility grid at no cost or risk to Michigan ratepayers. We have a tremendous opportunity to capitalize on EPA grant funding to help more families save money and take control of where their energy comes from. We can create a cleaner, brighter and more sustainable future for all Michigan residents with community solar.”

“Our Legislature and Gov. Gretchen Whitmer should enable community solar in our state’s transition to 100% clean energy,” said Nick Occhipinti, government affairs director at The Michigan League of Conservation Voters. “Community solar allows those who can’t install rooftop solar to take part in Michigan’s clean energy future, while lowering their monthly energy bills and reducing pollution in our air and water. This bipartisan legislation will pave the way for community-led solar projects and we urge lawmakers to unleash this opportunity giving Michiganders more access to affordable solar energy.”

“Community organizations in Michigan have been trying to create community solar programs for more than a decade — they’ve developed models, negotiated settlements, and advocated to regulators to no avail,” said Dr. Denise Keele, Executive Director at Michigan Climate Action Network. “Twenty-two other states already enable community solar, and advancing this bi-partisan legislation would finally allow all Michiganders to embrace and benefit from the fastest growing segment of the U.S. solar market.”  

“Community solar legislation is necessary for Michigan to gain the greatest number of benefits of Solar For All,” said John Delurey, senior midwest director at Vote Solar. “Michigan received $156 million through the Solar For All program to benefit low- or moderate-income households. EGLE’s proposal projects that more than 90% of the solar deployed will be community solar. That’s more than $100 million of public investment that could be generating benefits for both local and community ownership. Without taking legislative action now, these projects will be dominated by utility interests, and we’ll miss that opportunity.”   

“It is time to pass community solar legislation that includes third-party community solar programs to help achieve 100% clean energy by 2040 under Michigan’s clean energy law,” said Andrea Pierce, Michigan Environmental Justice Coalition (MEJC) policy manager. "We have an important opportunity to use EPA grant funding to assist low-income, black, Indigenous, people of color and families to save money, take control of where their energy comes from and hold big utilities accountable. Doctors say transitioning to clean energy will reduce rates of asthma, heart disease, lung disease and even cancer — especially for children and seniors. Now is the time to create a cleaner and more sustainable future that benefits ALL Michiganders.”

“With the Legislature’s support, community organizations stand ready to make community solar projects with tangible community benefits a reality for everyone in Michigan — regardless of your race, income or if you own a home,” said Alexis Blizman, Ecology Center legislative and policy director. “It’s time to create a transformative policy and start building projects that offer real community benefits.”

“As Michigan continues to emerge as a national climate leader, it’s important to ensure that all Michiganders feel the economic and health benefits of the state’s growing clean energy economy. By passing community solar, Michigan can unlock the door for low-income communities and renters to access the cost-saving benefits of solar energy,” said Courtney Bourgoin, Evergreen Action Midwest senior policy and advocacy manager. “Enacting community solar will lower energy prices, give Michiganders alternative choices beyond monopoly electric utilities, and help ensure that Michigan’s massive $154 million Solar for All award works effectively and equitably across the state. Let’s get it done.”

“Community solar legislation is an opportunity to improve the health and well-being of all Michigan residents, especially those who have suffered the greatest health impacts from fossil fuel pollution,” said Dr. Elizabeth (Lisa) Del Buono MD, founder and president of Michigan Clinicians for Climate Action. Such legislation would not only expedite the build out of healthy, clean solar energy in a more democratic and equitable fashion, but it would also protect health by improving the resilience of the grid. As extreme weather becomes more common in Michigan, dependable and affordable electricity can literally be the difference between life and death for those dependent on electricity to provide oxygen to breathe and for those whose health cannot withstand the increasingly common extreme heat, humidity, and poor air quality.  Let’s seize this opportunity to improve the health of ALL Michigan residents today!”

### 
 

Uncovering PFAS in Rainwater: A Community Study

In recent years, there has been growing concern about the accumulation of PFAS (per- and polyfluoroalkyl substances) in air and its spread through rainwater. Ecology Center collaborated with Great Lakes PFAS Action Network, Original United Citizens of Southwest Detroit, and Environmental Transformation Movement of Flint on a community-driven initiative that involved the collection and testing of rainwater in Detroit, Flint and Dearborn to understand the presence of PFAS in the environment. 

The Community Initiative

Community activists and environmental justice advocates in Detroit, Dearborn, Flint and Ann Arbor joined forces to better understand PFAS accumulation in the air around heavily industrial areas in Southeast Michigan and how it impacts residents. The Ecology Center provided funding and technical support for this project, and worked with community partners to pilot the study. 

Using buckets, rainwater samples were collected in Dearborn, Detroit, and Ann Arbor by community partners and analyzed by the College of Wooster. The analysis utilized the EPA’s method to measure 43 PFAS compounds, including TFA (trifluoroacetic acid), a breakdown product of common refrigerants used in air conditioning.

The results revealed the presence of PFAS in all three rainwater samples. Dearborn and Ann Arbor contained high levels of TFA. Several other PFAS chemicals, including legacy compounds PFOS and PFOA, were also detected. When TFA wasn’t accounted for, Dearborn and Detroit had the highest total PFAS. 

“We’ve long advocated for stronger environmental protections when it comes to the tens of thousands of synthetic chemicals currently used by industry. Until our society commits to regulating harmful substances as chemical classes, rather than one by one, this story of chemical bad guys and disillusioned communities will continue to repeat.” - Gillian Miller, Senior Scientist at Ecology Center 

Implications and Action Needed

The presence of multiple PFAS chemicals in rainwater, many at relatively high concentrations, emphasizes the urgent need for stronger regulations and environmental safeguards. The findings highlight the failures of the existing laws to protect human health and wildlife from the harmful effects of PFAS contamination. It is imperative to shift towards a precautionary approach in regulating new and emerging chemicals, prioritizing regulations on chemicals that accumulate and persist in the environment and lead to widespread, long-lasting, and increasing contamination. Current regulations are driven only by risk analysis, which has allowed dangerous and persistent chemicals to infect our environment, water, air, and products, putting our and our world’s health at risk. 

Key Takeaways

  • Rainwater collected in Ann Arbor, Detroit, and Dearborn was tested for PFAS and significant levels of TFA were found in Dearborn and Ann Arbor. 
  • This is a pilot study that collected rainwater on multiple rain events, which could impact PFAS levels in each sample. 
  • This study highlights the urgent need for regulatory action to address the presence of PFAS in rainwater.

The initiative to test rainwater for PFAS in Detroit and Dearborn exemplifies the power of community-driven environmental action, a cause the Ecology Center is dedicated to. The discovery of abundant PFAS in rainwater underscores the importance of collaborative efforts in addressing environmental challenges and advocating for stronger federal and state regulations to safeguard public and environmental health.

To read the full Healthy Stuff Lab study, click here.


June 26 Update

Local non-profit news organization Planet Detroit recently released an article series about Living with PFAS in Metro Detroit. Click Here to read more!